Don’t Fret®
Frequently Asked QuestionsThe most recent study of this issue (Louis Bergonzi, "Effects of Finger Markers and Harmonic Context on Performance of Beginning String Students", Journal of Research in Music Education, 1997, v.45, no. 2) concluded that students using finger position markers played much better in tune compared to students not using them. Suzuki himself used finger position markers, and their long tradition of acceptance in violin pedagogy is indicated by the fact that the three great baroque treatises on violin playing (Francesco Geminiani, Michel Corrette, and Leopold Mozart) advocated their use. Finger position markers give students a consistent input to train the judgment for intonation correctly and quickly. This increases the efficiency of their learning, their security with the instrument, and their sense of accomplishment.
Students do and will use their ear, but the question is how to develop an accurate sense of pitch most quickly. If students’ playing is out of tune or inconsistent, their ear soon learns to accept it, and proper auditory development is delayed rather than enhanced.
Bergonzi (see above) also studied this issue, and found that the use of finger position markers improved students’ intonation independently of the use of recordings. The group of students in his study who improved the most was that which used both pre-recorded cassettes and finger position markers, with more of the improvement being attributed to finger position markers. Also, in our highly visual culture, many kids’ primary learning style is visual.
You will be a more effective teacher. The teacher can use the Don’t Fret both to shape the auditory sense and to teach intervals, especially half- and whole-steps. Since the student has a secure guide to placing the fingers, the teacher is also freer to deal with other aspects of playing: technique, rhythm, etc. The Don’t Fret also simplifies the teaching of scales, keys, high- and low- finger positions, and (for ‘cello) extensions.
Not at all! Don’t Fret is simply a tool that gives the student and the teacher a concrete reference to the correct placement of the fingers. As such, it enhances the clarity and precision of any methodology.
Experience indicates that most students use the Don’t Fret to learn new notes, and thereafter refer to it only when they suspect that they are out of tune. In this way it reinforces auditory development, and increases the efficiency of their learning.
Those students who start string study with a strong musical background hardly look at the Don’t Fret---they know the structure of musical tones and have good auditory skills.
Those students whose auditory skills seem the least developed are the most dependent upon it initially, but as their auditory proficiency increases, their use of the Don’t Fret declines. Once the student shows signs of being self-correcting in intonation, the Don’t Fret should be removed.